Pan’s Anniversary, or The Shepherd’s Holiday (1621)

Edited by Martin Butler

INTRODUCTION

Pan’s Anniversary is dated 1625 in the 1640–1 folio, but this cannot be correct for the masque for that Christmas was The Fortunate Isles. Fortunately a transcript has survived of a bill (the original of which is now lost) detailing the expenditure on the antimasque costumes (see Masque Archive, Pan’s Ann., 8). This is dated ‘Xmas 1620’, which presumably means ‘the Christmas season 1620–1’, making Pan’s Anniversary the masque danced on Twelfth Night 1621, and repeated on Shrove Sunday (11 February). The identification is confirmed by the one concrete detail about the 1621 masque that we have, a report mentioned by the letter-writer John Chamberlain that some spectators were offended because ‘there was a puritan brought in to be flouted and abused’ (Chamberlain, Letters, ed. McClure, 1939, 2.333). This must have been the ‘prophet’ or fanatical tailor who, with his clock-keeper, mousetrap-maker, and clerk, disrupted the orderly rituals performed by the Arcadian shepherds. An older critical tradition, initiated by F. G. Fleay (1891), 2.14, and developed by Rudolph Brotanek (1902), 357, held that Pan’s Anniversary was an entertainment for King James’s birthday (19 June). However, this is no more than a guess, and there is no evidence to support it. No tradition existed of summer masques at court, and the masque uses the word ‘Anniversary’ not to mean a birthday but in its religious sense, appropriate for Christmas festivities, of ‘annual commemoration’. Only a misplaced feeling that the masque’s springtide motifs should have matched the winter season has prevented its true date from being recognized (see Butler, 1992a). Several other masques – such as Mercury Vindicated, The Vision of Delight, and Campion’s Lord Hay’s Masque (1607) – use Christmas festivities to anticipate springtide renewal, and sometimes claim that the monarch’s presence confers warmth even though the season is winter.

The celebration was held in the hall at Whitehall (the first Jacobean Banqueting House had burned down in 1619 and its successor was still in the process of rebuilding). The performance was politically sensitive because at this moment James was under pressure on two diplomatic fronts. The long-term issue was the future of his son-in-law, the Palatine Prince Frederick. In 1618 Frederick had accepted the crown of Bohemia, offered to him by the Bohemian Protestants, who were in revolt against their elected king, the future Habsburg emperor Ferdinand. The Habsburgs took swift revenge, ousting Frederick by force from his new kingdom and then from his own hereditary lands in Germany. In January 1621 James was about to meet his first parliament for seven years, and many people hoped he would use the opportunity to finance practical military support to restore his son-in-law to his territories; in the London streets, a significant popular political consciousness had started to develop (Butler, 1992a, 380–1). At the same time, James was newly welcoming a French ambassador extraordinary, the Marquis du Cadenet. Cadenet brought offers of French support for England in Germany, but the price was that England should refrain from criticizing Louis ⅩⅢ for the action he was about to take against his Protestant subjects, the Huguenots. In the event, James rejected the French requests, for he valued solidarity with co-religionists, and he was reluctant to be rushed into a German war. Cadenet was guest of honour at the Twelfth Night performance, and the masque’s pastoral theme, its satire on fanaticism, and its praise of strong government must have indicated that the English monarch was still firmly committed to peace. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the guest of honour at the second, Shrovetide performance was the Spanish ambassador, Gondomar.

The masque’s central device, a musical contest, derives in a general way from the Greek and Latin bucolic poets, in whom singing (though not dancing) competitions were a common motif (see 59–60n.). Jonson could have taken some hints for rural rituals in honour of Pan from Michael Drayton’s The Man in the Moon (1606) and from passages of Silius Italicus including The Fountain of Ancient Fiction, translated from Cartari by Richard Linche (1599), sig. I3, but most of the pastoral furniture is his own invention. To create his Arcadia, he drew widely on classical sources and on native pastoral traditions reaching back into the Elizabethan period by way of Shakespeare, Spenser, and Sidney. He extended the pastoral form by linking James not with the puckish Pan of Homeric myth but with the more formidable Pan of the Orphic hymns, whose presence mysteriously pervades the Arcadian landscape. Pan’s Anniversary was the most elaborate court pastoral staged thus far at Stuart Whitehall, prefiguring a form that eventually came into fuller vogue under Charles I. Many Caroline pastorals would praise the serenity of the nation, but in Jonson’s masque England’s strength seems to issue directly from the imperious but pacific deity who presides over the occasion. Peace is guaranteed by a masterful kingly power who loves his people but demands their obedience.

The only text of Pan’s Anniversary appears in F2. Four closely similar landscape sketches by Inigo Jones may be survivals from the scene designs prepared for its performance (see Illustration 80; and 0 n.). No music for the masque has been identified, though the staging must have involved a sharp aural contrast between the Boeotians’ unrefined dancing, led by a noisy drum (see 75–8), and the harmonious strains accompanying the masquers. A ‘Shepherds Dance’ in British Library Add. MS 10444 has been sometimes been linked with Pan’s Anniversary, though with little certainty (Walls, 1996, 125). Material from this masque was later adapted by Jonson as ‘A New Year’s Gift Sung to King Charles, 1635’ (Und. 79), and at least part of this was set to music by Nicholas Lanier. An elaborate revival of Pan’s Anniversary, with music by Vaughan Williams and Holst, was mounted by the Shakespeare Club of Stratford-upon-Avon in 1905; a further revival took place at Avery Hill College, Eltham, in 1928; and parts of the masque were set to music in Sir Arthur Bliss’s choral work, Pastoral: ‘Lie Strewn the White Flocks’, 1929 (see Performance Archive).

[Illustration 80: Inigo Jones, design for a proscenium and landscape scene for Pan’s Anniversary.

 

PAN'S ANNIVERSARY,
OR THE  SHEPHERDS' HOLIDAY
The Scene, Arcadia

 As it was presented at court before King James,  1621 The Inventors
Inigo Jones Ben  Jonson

The first presentation is of three NYMPHS

 

strewing several sorts of flowers

,

followed by an

old SHEPHERD with a

 

censer and perfumes

.

FIRST NYMPH

  Thus,thus, begin the yearly rites

Are due to Pan on these bright nights;

His   moon now riseth and invites 5

To sports, to dances and delights;

All envious and profane, away!

This is the shepherds’  holiday.

SECOND NYMPH

Strew, strew the glad and smiling ground

With every flower, yet not confound 10

The  primrose  drop, the spring’s own  spouse,

Bright  daisies and the  lips of cows,

The  garden-star, the  queen of May,

The rose to crown the holiday.

THIRD NYMPH

Drop, drop, you violets! Change your hues, 15

Now red, now pale, as lovers  use,

And in your death go out as well

As when you  lived, unto the smell,

That from your odour all may say

This is the shepherds’ holiday. 20

SHEPHERD

Well done, my pretty ones! Rain roses still,

Until the last be  dropped; then hence, and fill

Your fragrant  prickles for a second  shower.

 Bring  corn-flag, tulips, and  Adonis’ flower,

Fair  ox-eye,  goldilocks, and columbine, 25

Pinks,  goulands,  king-cups, and sweet  sops-in-wine,

Blue harebells,  paigles, pansies,  calaminth,

 Flower-gentle, and the fair-haired hyacinth;

Bring rich carnations,  flower-de-luces, lilies,

 The checked and purple-ringèd daffodillies, 30

Bright  crown-imperial,  king’s spear, hollyhocks,

Sweet  Venus’ navel, and soft  lady-smocks;

Bring too some branches forth of  Daphne’s hair,

And gladdest  myrtle for these posts to wear

With  spikenard weaved, and marjoram between, 35

And starred with  yellow-golds and  meadow’s queen,

That when the altar, as it ought, is dressed,

More odour come not from the  phoenix’ nest;

The  breath thereof  Panchaia may envy,

The colours  China, and the light the sky. 40

 

Loud music. The scene opens, and in it are the MASQUERS discovered sitting about the

 

fountain of

 

light, the MUSICIANS attired like the priests of Pan standing in the work

beneath them, when

 

entereth to the old Shepherd a FENCER

 

flourishing.

FENCER

 Room for an old trophy of time, a son of the sword, a servant of Mars,

the minion of the muses, and a master of fence! One that hath shown his 45

 quarters and played his  prizes at all the games of Greece in his time, as

fencing, wrestling, leaping, dancing, what  not; and hath now ushered hither

by the light of my  long-sword certain bold boys of   Boeotia, who are come

to challenge the Arcadians at their own sports, call them forth on their own

holiday, and dance them down on their own   greensward. 50

SHEPHERD

’Tis boldly attempted, and must be a  Boeotian enterprise by the

face of it, from all the parts of Greece else, especially at this time when the

best and bravest spirits of Arcadia, called together by the excellent  Arcas, are

yonder sitting about the fountain of light, in consultation of what honours

they may do the great  Pan by increase of anniversary rites fitted to the  music 55

of his peace.

FENCER

Peace to thy Pan, and mum to thy music, swain. There is a tinker of

 Thebes a-coming, called  Epam, with his  kettle will make all Arcadia ring of

him. What are your sports for the purpose? Say;  if singing, you shall be sung

down, if dancing, danced down. There is no more to be done with you but 60

know  what, which it is; and you are in smoke, gone, vapoured, vanished,

blown, and, as a man would say in a word of two syllables, nothing.

SHEPHERD

This is  short, though not so sweet. Surely the better part of the

solemnity here will be dancing.

FENCER

Enough; they shall be met with instantly in their own sphere, the 65

sphere of their own   activity, a dance. But by whom,  expect: no   Cynaethian,

nor satyrs, but, as I said, boys of Boeotia, things of Thebes – the town is ours,

shepherd – mad  merry Greeks, lads of life that have no gall in us, but all air

and sweetness. A  tooth-drawer is our foreman, that if there be but a bitter

tooth in the company, it may be called out at a  twitch. He doth command 70

any man’s teeth out of his head upon the point of his  poniard, or tickles

them forth with his riding rod; he draws teeth a-horseback in full speed, yet

he will dance  a-foot, he hath given his  word. He is  yeoman of the mouth to

the whole brotherhood, and is charged to see their gums be clean and their

breath sweet at a minute’s warning. Then comes my  learned Theban, the 75

tinker I told you of, with his kettledrum before and after, a master of music

and a man of   mettle; he beats the march to the tune of  Ticklefoot, pam, pam,

pam, brave Epam with a  nondas. That’s the  strain.

SHEPHERD

A  high one!

FENCER

Which is followed by the  trace and tract of an excellent juggler, that 80

can juggle with every joint about him from head to heel. He can do tricks

with his toes, wind silk and thread pearl with them, as nimble a fine fellow

of his feet as his hands; for there is a noble  corn-cutter his companion, hath

so pared and  finified   them –. Indeed, he hath taken it into his care to reform

the feet of all, and fit all their footing  to a form; only  one  splay-foot in the 85

company, and he is a  bellows-mender,   allowed, who hath the looking to of

all their lungs by patent, and by his place is to  set that leg afore still, and with

his puffs keeps them in breath during pleasure;  a tinderbox-man to strike

new fire into them at every turn, and where he spies any brave  spark that is

in danger to go out, ply him with a  match  presently. 90

SHEPHERD

A most  politic provision!

FENCER

Nay, we have made our provisions  beyond example, I hope. For to

these there is annexed a  clock-keeper, a grave person as Time himself, who is

to see that they all keep time  to a nick, and move every elbow in order, every

knee  in compass. He is to wind them up, and draw them  down, as he sees 95

 cause. Then is there a subtle  shrewd-bearded sir, that hath been a  politician

but is now a  maker of mousetraps, a great  engineer yet, and he is to catch the

ladies’ favours in the dance with certain  cringes he is to make, and to bait their

 benevolence. Nor can we doubt of the success, for we have a  prophet amongst

us of that  peremptory  pate, a tailor or master  fashioner, that hath found 100

it out in a  painted cloth, or some old hanging – for those are his library –

that we must conquer in such a time and  such a half time, therefore bids us

go on  cross-legged, or however thread the needles of our own happiness,  go

through-stitch withal, unwind the  clew of our  cares; he hath taken measure

of our minds, and will fit our fortune to our  footing. And to better assure 105

us, at his own charge brings his philosopher with him,  a great clerk, who

(they say) can write, and it is shrewdly suspected but he can read too; and he

is to take the whole dances from the foot by  brachygraphy, and so make a

 memorial, if not a  map of the business. – [Calling] Come forth, lads, and do

your own turns. 110

The antimasque is

 

danced, after which,

FENCER

How like you this, shepherd? Was not this  gear gotten on a holiday?

SHEPHERD

Faith, your folly may deserve pardon because it hath delighted;

but beware of presuming, or how you offer  comparison with  persons so near

deities. Behold where  they are that  have now forgiven you, whom should you 115

provoke again with  the like, they will justly punish that with anger which

they now dismiss with contempt. Away!

[The antimasquers withdraw.]

And come you prime Arcadians forth, that  taught

By Pan the rites of true society, 120

From his loud music all your manners wrought,

And made your commonwealth a harmony,

Commending so to all  posterity

Your innocence from  that fair fount of light,

As  still you sit  without the injury 125

Of any rudeness  folly can, or spite;

Dance from the top of the  Lycaean mountain

Down to this valley, and with nearer eye

Enjoy what long in that illumined fountain

You did far off, but yet with wonder, spy. 130

 

First Hymn

FIRST PRIEST

  Of Pan we sing, the best of singers, Pan,

That taught us swains how first to tune our lays,

And on the pipe more airs than  Phoebus  can.

CHORUS

Hear, O you groves, and hills resound his praise. 135

SECOND PRIEST

Of Pan we sing, the best of leaders, Pan,

That leads the  naiads and the dryads forth,

And to their dances more than  Hermes can.

CHORUS

Hear, O you groves, and hills resound his worth.

THIRD PRIEST

Of Pan we sing, the best of hunters, Pan, 140

That drives the  hart to seek unusèd ways,

And in the chase more than  Silvanus can.

CHORUS

Hear, O you groves, and hills resound his praise.

FOURTH PRIEST

Of Pan we sing, the best of shepherds, Pan,

That keeps our flocks and us, and both leads forth 145

To better pastures than great  Pales can.

CHORUS

Hear, O you groves, and hills resound his worth.

And while his powers and praises thus we sing,

The valleys let rebound, and all the rivers ring.

The masquers descend, and dance their entry.

150

Second Hymn

PRIESTS

 Pan is our  All;  by him we breathe, we live,

We move, we are. ’Tis he our lambs doth rear,

Our flocks doth bless, and from the store doth give

The warm and finer fleeces that we wear. 155

He keeps away all heats and colds,

Drives all diseases from our folds,

Makes everywhere the spring to dwell,

The ewes to feed, their udders swell;

 But if he frown, the sheep, alas, 160

The shepherds wither, and the grass.

Strive, strive, to please him then by still increasing thus

The rites  are due to him, who doth all right for us.

The main dance.

Third Hymn

165

PRIESTS

If yet, if yet

Pan’s  orgies you will further fit,

See where the silver-footed  fays do sit,

The nymphs of wood and water,

Each tree’s and fountain’s  daughter. 170

Go take them forth; it will be good

To see some wave it like a wood,

And others wind it like a flood,

In springs

And rings, 175

Till the applause it brings

Wakes  Echo from her seat,

The  closes to repeat.

ECHO

 The closes to repeat.

PRIESTS

Echo, the truest oracle on ground, 180

Though nothing but a sound,

ECHO

Though nothing but a sound,

PRIESTS

Beloved of Pan, the valley’s queen,

ECHO

The valley’s queen,

PRIESTS

And often heard, though never seen. 185

ECHO

Though never seen.

 

Revels.

FENCER

Room, room there! Where are you, shepherd? I am come again with

my second part of my bold bloods, the brave  gamesters, who assure you by

me that they perceive no such wonder in all is done here but that they dare 190

adventure another trial. They look for some sheepish devices here in Arcadia,

not these, and therefore   ‘A hall, a hall!’ they demand.

SHEPHERD

Nay, then, they are past pity; let them come, and not expect the anger

of a deity to pursue them, but meet them. They have their punishment with

their  fact. They shall be sheep. 195

FENCER

Oh, spare me, by  the law of nations! I am but their ambassador.

SHEPHERD

You speak  in time, sir.

  

Second antimasque

[of Boeotians with sheeps’ heads].

SHEPHERD

Now let them return with their  solid heads, and carry their

stupidity into  Boeotia whence they brought it, with an emblem of themselves and 200

 their country. This is too pure an air for so gross brains.

End you the rites, and so be eased

Of these, and then great Pan is pleased.

[The antimasquers withdraw.]

Fourth Hymn

205

PRIESTS

Great Pan, the father of our peace and pleasure,

Who giv’st us all this leisure,

Hear what thy hallowed troop of herdsmen pray

For this their holiday,

And how their vows to thee they in  Lycaeum pay. 210

 So may our ewes receive the mounting rams,

And we bring thee the earliest of our lambs;

So may the first of all our  fells be thine,

And both the  beestning of our goats and  kine;

As thou our folds dost still secure, 215

And keep’st our fountains sweet and pure,

Driv’st hence the wolf, the   tod, the  brock,

Or other vermin from the flock;

That we preserved by thee, and thou observed by us,

May both live safe in shade of thy loved  Maenalus. 220

SHEPHERD

Now each return unto his charge,

And though today you have lived at large,

And well your flocks have fed their fill,

Yet do not trust your  hirelings  still.

See, yond’ they go, and timely do 225

The office you have put them to,

But if you often give this leave,

Your sheep and you they will deceive.


 THE END

Title SHEPHERDS’ HOLIDAY] SHEPHERDS / HOLY-DAY F2
0 No scene is described in F2, but it seems likely that Inigo Jones’s setting was based on one of the group of related designs of c. 1621 showing a mountain landscape bordered with trees, of which Illustration 80 is the best example (for the others, see Orgel and Strong, 1.320–27).
1621] this edn; 1625 F2; 1620 H&S
Jonson] F2 (Iohnson)
1 strewing . . . flowers The same action opened Campion’s Lord Hay’s Masque (1607).
2 censer Also used in Love’s Tr., 70. Here it suggests that the masque is a religious rite, which the antimasquers interrupt: the songs between the dances are all titled ‘Hymn’, and the word ‘holiday’ is throughout printed as ‘holy-day’.
3, 9, 15 first (second, third) nymph] NYMPH I. (Ⅱ., Ⅲ.) F2
5 moon] this edn; Morne F2
5 moon The mention of ‘bright nights’ (4) suggests that F2’s ‘Morne’ is probably a scribal or compositorial error for ‘Moone’. Perhaps Inigo Jones’s design included an artificial moon that crossed the sky during the evening, as happened in Oberon and Vision.
8 holiday] Holy-day F2 (and so throughout)
11 primrose] F2 (Prime-rose)
11 drop hanging blossom.
11 spouse i.e. Because it is the earliest spring flower and conventionally marks the arrival of spring. Cf. Drayton’s Poly-Olbion (ed. Hebel, 1961), 15.150–1: ‘The primrose placing first, because that in the spring / It is the first appears, then only flourishing’. The action of the masque is unseasonably cast as a springtide celebration, but this testifies to James’s miraculous power of creating spring warmth even in the midst of winter. See the Introduction.
12 daisies] F2 (Dayes-eyes)
12 lips of cows cowslips (a false etymology).
13 garden-star Probably star of Bethlehem (Bath asparagus), an edible herb used in May garlands (conj. Julie Sanders, privately).
13 queen of May Probably, hawthorn, whose blossoms are named ‘may’ after the season.
16 use do, make it their practice.
18 lived,] H&S, after Nichols; liv’d F2
22 dropped] F3 (subst.); drapt F2
23 prickles wicker baskets, for flowers and fruit.
23 shower.] G; shower, F2
24–36 A passage recollecting the flower catalogues endemic to pastoral poetry. The precedents set by Theocritus (11.56–7), Bion (1.75–6), Moschus (3.5–7), and Virgil’s Eclogues (2.45–50) were imitated in the Renaissance by Marot, Castiglione, and others. Jonson’s principal English model is the flower-list in the April eclogue of Spenser’s Shepherd’s Calendar (1579), which he borrows from and greatly extends: ‘Bring hether the Pincke and purple Cullambine, / With Gelliflowres: / Bring Coronations, and Sops in wine, / Worne of Paramoures. / Strowe me the ground with Daffadowndillies, / And Cowslips, and Kingcups, and loued Lillies: / The pretie Pawnce, / And the Cheuisaunce, / Shall match with the fayre flower Delice’ (April, 136–44). There are also reminiscences of the pastoral episodes in WT.
24 corn-flag gladiolus.
24 Adonis’ flower the anemone, which sprung from the dying Adonis’s blood (Ovid, Met., 10.739); or according to Bion (1.66), the rose.
25 ox-eye corn-marigold.
25 goldilocks A species of buttercup.
26 goulands crowfoot, or marsh-marigolds.
26 king-cups the common buttercup; a dialect name used in The Shepherd’s Calendar, April, 141; called ‘kingcobs’ in Gerard’s Herbal (1597), 805.
26 sops-in-wine gillyflower or clove-pink: The Shepherd’s Calendar, April, 138.
27 paigles cowslips; a dialect name, like many in this list.
27 calaminth calamint; an aromatic and medicinal herb.
28 Flower-gentle Floramour, a species of amaranthus; a purple velvet flower reputed never to fade.
29 flower-de-luces white irises. The fleur-de-lys is the heraldic lily borne on the arms of France, but botanically it is a different flower; Spenser calls it the lily’s ‘lovely paramour’ (The Faerie Queene, 2.6.16). See also Shepherd’s Calendar, April, 144, and WT, 4.4.127.
30 The checked . . . daffodillies The snake’s head, a species of fritillary (Fritillaria Meleagris). ‘Daffodilly’ is a poeticized form deriving from Spenser, as in The Shepherd’s Calendar, January eclogue, 22.
31 crown-imperial Fritillaria imperialis, which has flowers encompassing the stalk like a crown. Admired by Perdita in WT, 4.4.126.
31 king’s spear yellow asphodel.
32 Venus’ navel pennywort, a weed that grows in crevices and walls.
32 lady-smocks cuckoo-flowers (see LLL, 5.2.905).
33 Daphne’s hair laurel, into which Daphne was turned as she tried to escape from Apollo.
34 myrtle Sacred to Venus, and emblematic of love.
35 spikenard An aromatic eastern plant; the name was sometimes used for lavender.
36 yellow-golds marigolds.
36 meadow’s queen meadowsweet, a tall plant with white, fragrant flowers.
38 phoenix’ nest The pyre of aromatic twigs on which the phoenix died and was mysteriously reborn (see Highgate, 107).
39 breath] Wh; breadth F2
39 Panchaia A mythical island east of Arabia, famous for its spices (see Highgate, 105). There may be a general reminiscence of Claudian’s De raptu Proserpinae (‘The Rape of Proserpine’), 2.323–5, which cites both Panchaia and the phoenix as instances of paradisal sweetness.
40 China i.e. Because of the delicate colours in the newly imported china-ware.
41–3 In comparison with other masques, the discovery of the masquers comes at a remarkably early point in the evening. It was customary for the masquers to appear at the end of the antimasques, making a decisive break between antimasque and masque. On this occasion, however, their presence is disclosed long in advance of their technical entry, the point at which they step down from the stage to dance. The shepherd later explains (129–30) that they spend the antimasque silently contemplating the glory of Pan (i.e. King James); his phrase ‘long in that illumined fountain’ (129) indicates that they were visible above the stage for some considerable time. This unusual circumstance underlines that the antimasquers break into what ought to be a dignified court ritual.
42 fountain of light Inigo Jones’s signature effect: the masques are discovered in the middle of a glorious and focused display of candle-power. See Gold. Age, 126n.
42 light, the] Nichols; light. ∣ The F2
43 entereth] F2 (entreth)
43 flourishing brandishing his weapon.
44 SH] Wh; not in F2
46 quarters bodily parts. Or perhaps the Fencer means it in the heraldic sense, the four parts of an escutcheon, each bearing armorial symbols.
46 prizes matches.
47 not; and] Orgel; not? And F2
48 long-sword heavy, old-fashioned sword.
48, 67 Boeotia] F2 (Bæotia)
48 Boeotia A district of Greece bordering onto Attica. In classical literature, its inhabitants are proverbially stupid and uncouth, the foils to Athenian civility; see Pindar, Olympian Odes, 6.90: ‘the ancient words of shame, swine of Boeotia’; Horace, Epistles (trans. Fairelough, 1970), 2.1.244: ‘the gross air of the Boeotians’; and Erasmus, Adages, 1.10.6, 2.3.7.
50 greensward] F2 (Greene-swarth)
50 greensward grassy turf; referring figuratively to the dancing floor, which at masques was covered with green cloth.
51 Boeotian] F2 (Bæotian)
53 Arcas The eponymous king of Arcadia, son of Zeus and Callisto, and companion of Artemis (mentioned in Pausanias, 8.4.1, and Apollodorus, 3.8.2–3.9.1): a suitably elevated role for Prince Charles.
55 Pan The god of Arcadia, here used to figure King James. Jonson’s treatment ignores the shaggy and puckish local deity of Homeric tradition, and invokes the more dignified figure who appears in the Orphic Hymn to Pan, a mysterious cosmic overlord whose presence is secretly diffused through all nature, and whose name, through a false etymology, was believed to mean ‘the All’, the wholeness of things. See 152n. below; Oberon, 271; and Butler (1992a), 372–5.
55–6 music . . . peace Alluding to James’s pursuit of European rapprochement.
58 Thebes Chief city of Boeotia.
58 Epam Short for Epaminondas (see 78 below); historically a great general, who in bc 371–62 led Thebes to victories against Sparta. See Discoveries, 260–1.
58 kettle kettledrum (see 76). The Boeotians’ music is noisy and unrefined; a similar effect, using tabors, happens in Pleasure Rec., 3.
59–60 if singing . . . danced down This challenge alludes to the singing contests that are sometimes found in classical literature, exemplified by Theocritus’s Idyll 6, 8, and 9, and Virgil’s Eclogue 3, and imitated in some Renaissance pastorals, such as the August eclogue of Spenser’s Shepherd’s Calendar. Jonson’s characters stage a contest that is the dancing equivalent. There may also be an underlying reminiscence of the myth of Marsyas, who was challenged by Apollo to a music competition and, having lost, was flayed alive. Marsyas’s instrument, the aulos or double-flute, was particularly beloved of the Boeotians. See also 134n.
61 what,] Orgel; what; F2
63 short . . . sweet Playing on the proverbial idiom, ‘short and sweet’ (Dent, S396).
66 activity,] F3; activitie F2
66 activity Cf. Christmas, 248.
66 expect pay attention (from Lat. expecto, –are to look out for).
66 Cynaethian] F2 (Cynætheian)
66 Cynaethian From Cynaetha, a town in northern Arcadia.
68 merry Greeks roisterers. A proverbial idiom: see Dent, M901, and OED, Greek, n. 5, and Grig, n. 5.
69 tooth-drawer dentist. Cf. Bart. Fair, Induction, 91.
70 twitch. He] this edn; twitch; he F2
71 poniard dagger.
73 a-foot] F2 (a foote)
73 word.] this edn; word: F2
73 yeoman . . . mouth Anciently the title of an office in the royal household. ‘Yeoman of our larder for our mouth’ is recorded from 1450 (OED, Mouth, n. 1d).
75 learned Theban Cf. Lear, 3.4.153, where Lear uses this phrase for Mad Tom. Lear is perhaps referring to Crates, a cynic philosopher and follower of Diogenes, but in the masque the phrase is wholly ironic.
77 mettle] F2 (mettall)
77 mettle (1) courage; (2) metal (being a tinker).
77 Ticklefoot Perhaps the name of a dance tune? Cf. Gypsies (Burley) 446, and Bolsover, 56.
78 nondas A nonce-word, playing on the name of the general Epaminondas after whom the tinker is named (see 58 above).
78 strain melody (OED, Strain, n.2, 13a).
79 high Punning on ‘high-strained’ = overstretched, forced.
80 trace and tract footsteps.
83 corn-cutter quack chiropodist. Cf. Bart. Fair, The Persons of the Play, 27.
84 finified spruced up.
84 them –.] F2
84 them –. Indeed The dash, and the subsequent break in the sense, correspond to the text as it appears in F2. Perhaps something has dropped out, or was unreadable in the manuscript. See Textual Essay.
85 to a form to a model; playing on ‘reform’ (84).
85 one splay-foot] Wh; ones play-foot F2
85 splay-foot person whose feet turn out in a clumsy manner.
86 bellows-mender Like Flute, in MND.
86 allowed,] F3 (subst.); allow’d F2
86 allowed licensed.
87 set . . . afore i.e. in a curtsy or bow.
88 tinderbox-man seller of tinderboxes. Cf. Bart. Fair, ‘Persons of the Play’, 26.
89 spark (1) burning particle; (2) dashing young man.
90 match A piece of wick or cord dipped in sulphur, and used to light candles, fuel, or firearms.
90 presently immediately.
91 politic shrewd, ingenious.
92 beyond example without any possible comparison (a boast, but unwittingly ironic).
93 clock-keeper Possibly the clock-keeper and/or the mousetrap man involved some sort of satirical reflection on David Ramsay (c. 1575–1660), the king’s clockmaker and patentee of various mechanical inventions and industrial processes. As a royal servant (Ramsay was a groom of the privy chamber and a person of some wealth), his status was much higher than that of these Boeotian citizens, but towards the end of his life Francis Osborne retailed an anecdote that linked him with Ball the puritan tailor alluded to below. See the full quotation at 99n.
94 to a nick down to the second.
95 in compass (1) in proportion with one another; (2) moderately.
95 down,] F3; downe F2
96 cause.] Morley; cause; F2
96 shrewd-bearded A beard is a sign of age, and hence wisdom, though this is ironically untrue for the mousetrap-maker. Cf. Gypsies (Burley and Windsor), 12–13: ‘the memorial of both their gravities, his in beard and hers in belly’; Cynthia (Q), Praeludium, 163–4: ‘Another, whom it hath pleased nature to furnish with more beard than brain’; and 2.3.69–70: ‘his face is another volume of essays, and his beard an Aristarchus’.
96 politician statesman; intriguer.
97 maker of mousetraps A ‘seller of mousetraps’ (a ghost character) is mentioned in Bart. Fair, Induction 108, and similarly associated there with a politician, probably because both are ‘engineers’, i.e. makers of cunning contrivances. For this sense of ‘engineer’, see also Bart. Fair, 2.2.13, Sej., 1.1.4, and the character Engine (a broker) in Devil.
97 engineer] F2 (Inginer)
98 cringes obsequious bows.
99 benevolence kindness (which his ‘cringes’ will ‘bait’, as if with cheese in a mousetrap).
99 prophet religious fanatic; specifically, a participant in the public religious exercises known as ‘prophesyings’ (Collinson, 1967, 168–76); someone who preaches or prays according to the inspiration of the Holy Spirit (OED, Prophet, n. 1c). Probably this figure is intended to glance at Ball the puritanical tailor, whose fanatical ‘discourses’ are satirized in the ‘Execration upon Vulcan’ (Und. 43.82) and Staple, 3.2.125 SD; these texts call him ‘Prophet Ball’ or ‘Baal’. In his rancorous history of James’s reign, Francis Osborne claimed that ‘one Ball a tailor was inspired with a like lunacy . . . for not only he, but Ramsay His Majesty’s watchmaker [see 93n. above] put out money and clocks to be paid (but with small advantage, considering the improbability) when King James should be crowned in the pope’s chair’ (Osborne, 1658, 118). Ball is also mentioned in Fletcher’s Fair Maid of the Inn (1625, ed. Bowers, 1966), 5.2.79 (‘the very Ball of your false prophets’), and is probably ‘the new prophet, the astrological tailor’ mentioned in Middleton’s Anything for a Quiet Life (1621), 5.1.
100 peremptory self-willed, dictatorial. Cf. Bart. Fair, 4.1.157, ‘parantory’.
100 pate brain.
100 fashioner costumier (like the Fashioner, or ‘tailor of the times’ in Staple, The Persons of the Play, 21).
101 painted cloth cheap tapestry; often decorated with biblical stories (cf. 1H4, 4.2.25). Also called ‘tailors’ libraries’ in Staple, 1.2.103. The implication is that the tailor is illiterate.
102 such . . . half time Echoing Revelation, 12.14. This puritan cant phrase is also ascribed to prophet Ball (or Baal) in Staple, 3.2.129.
103 cross-legged The posture in which tailors sat to work.
103–4 go through-stitch finish what’s begun. (Tailor’s phrase.)
104 clew ball of yarn.
104 cares;] F3; cares, F2
105 footing footwork.
106 a] F3; a a F2
108 brachygraphy shorthand. England was well ahead of other European countries in the development of shorthand, as it was particularly cultivated by the godly, who used it to take down notes or verbatim transcripts of sermons. The term ‘brachygraphy’ was popularized by Peter Bales’s The Art of Brachygraphy (1597; expanded from an earlier section of his The Writing Schoolmaster, 1590); but neither Bales’s system nor that in Timothy Bright’s Charactery (1588) were successful, both being cumbersome and difficult to learn. The earliest effective system was devised by John Willis, in The Art of Stenography (1602; fourteenth edition 1648).
109 memorial memorandum.
109 map A chart, but also with the (now obsolete) implication of an epitome, a representation in abridged form (OED 5, citing Sidney’s Astrophil and Stella, 6: ‘think that all the map of my state I display / When trembling voice brings forth that I do Stella love’).
111 danced, after] this edn; Daunced. ∣ After F2
112 gear gotten stuff begotten.
114 comparison to compare yourselves.
114–15 persons . . . deities As Orgel notes, this probably refers to the spectators, who, in the complimentary discourse of the masque (and from the perspective of the antimasquers) could be thought of as semi-divine. Alternatively, the masquers could be meant, but the reference to them as ‘prime Arcadians’ (119) signals a change of address which acknowledges them for the first time. It seems improbable that the masquers would ‘punish’ (116) the Boeotians, as they are in competition with them for dancing, but the spectators might well do so, out of ‘anger’ at their disrupting the court spectacle.
115 they the spectators.
115 have] Wh; are F2
116 the like more folly of the same sort.
119–22 taught . . . harmony Alluding to the Orphic idea that Pan’s music embodies the universe’s underlying concords.
123 posterity] Wh; posteritie. F2
124 that . . . light See 42 above.
125 still continually.
125 without beyond.
126 folly . . . spite that folly or spite can inflict.
127 Lycaean mountain Lycaeus, in Arcadia; Pan’s birthplace and shrine. See Theocritus, 1.123, and Pausanias, 8.38.5.
131, 151, 165, 205 First (Second, Third, Fourth) Hymn] this edn; HYMNE I. (Ⅱ., Ⅲ., ⅢⅠ.) F2
132, 136, 140, 144 SH first, second, third, fourth priest] this edn; 1. 2. 3. 4. F2
132–49 Jonson recycled this hymn as part of a New Year’s gift for Charles I, adapting it into lines 20–35 of Und. 79. Its strophic form and evocation of the landscape make it reminiscent of some of the lyrics in Philip Sidney’s Arcadia, while the refrain recalls that in Spenser’s ‘Epithalamion’ (1595): ‘The woods shall to me answer and my echo ring.’ The singers are designated by numbers in F2, but with no identification. Gifford assumes they were nymphs, and Orgel calls them ‘Arcadians’, but it seems likelier that they came from the musicians attired as Pan’s priests (42).
134 Phoebus Apollo, god of music. This stanza reverses the relationship of Pan and Apollo as it appeared in the story of Midas. Midas attended a musical contest between Pan and Apollo; he preferred Pan’s music, and was rewarded with a donkey’s ears (Ovid, Met., 11.146–93). See also 59–60n.
134 can can do.
137 naiads, dryads nymphs of river and forest.
138 Hermes Mercury, also born in Arcadia; linked with dancing through his associations with eloquence and the arts.
141 hart] F3; Heart F2
142 Silvanus God of the forest.
146 Pales Italian goddess of the countryside. See Virgil, Georgics, 3.1.1 (‘magna Pales’), and Ovid, Fasti, 4.722.
152, 166, 180, 183, 185, 206 SH priests] this edn; not in F1
152 All In the Renaissance this was still thought to be the literal meaning of Pan’s name, through a false etymology which associated it with the word πᾶν, which means ‘all’ in Greek (see 55n. above). The true etymology of ‘Pan’ is ‘the feeder’ or ‘herdsman’, but this more mystical interpretation was current in antiquity; see the Homeric Hymn to Pan, 47, and Plato, Cratylus, 408c–d.
152–3 by . . . are Echoing St Paul’s words to the Athenians: ‘in him we live and move and have our being’ (Acts, 17.28, Authorized Version).
160–3 These distinctly admonitory lines perhaps echo the Old Testament warnings that bad shepherds will be punished. Cf. Zechariah, 10.3 (‘Mine anger was kindled against the shepherds’) and 13.7 (‘Awake, O sword, against my shepherd . . . smite the shepherd, and the sheep shall be scattered’), Jeremiah, 51.23 (‘I will also break in pieces with thee the shepherd and his flock’), and Ezekiel, 34.2–6 (‘Woe be to the shepherds of Israel that do feed themselves . . . My sheep wandered through all the mountains, and upon every high hill: yea, my flock was scattered upon all the face of the earth, and none did search or seek after them’).
163 are that are.
167 orgies solemn rituals. See Hym., Jonson’s marginal note 11.
168 fays fairies, i.e. the women in the audience, with whom the masquers are now being invited to dance.
170 daughter.] after G; daughter, F2
177 Echo Usually depicted as pining away for love of Narcissus, but an alternative tradition makes her a nymph loved by Pan for her beauty and talent for singing. Frustrated at her coyness, Pan sent a madness among the shepherds, and they tore her to pieces; her limbs were scattered across the earth, where they continue to sing in the form of echoes. See Longus, Daphnis and Chloe, 3.23. Macrobius’s Saturnalia, 1.22, has a less violent version of the myth: in this she is married to Pan, and her echoes express the harmonies of his pipes.
178 closes cadences.
179, 182, 184, 186 ] SHs incorporated into the lines, and both enclosed in brackets F2
187 Revels The main social dances of the evening, when members of the audience would have joined the masquers in galliards and corantos.
189 gamesters performers of entertainment or of feats of activity, appropriate to the Christmas season. Cf. Christmas, 259: ‘come to the court, for to make you some sport’; and Shr., Induction 2.138: ‘A Christmas gambol, or a tumbling trick’.
192 ‘A hall, a hall’] this edn; a hall, a hall F2
192 A hall A cry for room, used by interluders entering a playing space. Cf. Tub, 5.9.11; and Owls, 1.
195 fact crime. Cf. EMI (F), 5.5.45.
196 the law of nations International law applies to the Fencer because he is a visitor and official representative from another state; being an ambassador, he can claim immunity from prosecution. The joke depends on the implied similarity between him and the ambassadors of modern European nations who would have been watching the performance in the hall. New concepts of diplomatic immunity were being forged in the crucible of the Thirty Years’ War, and the increased ambassadorial activity that it gave rise to. The most important philosophical formulation of these new concepts would come in Grotius’s De iure belli et pacis (1625): see Mattingley (1955), 256–68.
197 in time in the nick of time – because the other Boeotians have already been changed into sheep.
198 SD] this edn; 2. ANTIMASQUE F2
198 This is the first Jonsonian masque in which an extra antimasque arrives late, after the main dramatic business has seemingly ended. In all preceding masques, the antimasquers had been confined to the territory before the appearance of the main masquers. The device had been pioneered by Thomas Campion in The Masque of Squires (1613), and Jonson repeats it in Neptune’s Triumph. It is further imitated in some later masques, such as James Shirley’s Triumph of Peace (1634).
199 solid dense; ignorant.
200 Boeotia] this edn; Bœotia, F2
201 their country (Alluding to Boeotia’s reputation for stupidity.)
210 Lycaeum Mount Lycaeus.
211 A version of this line recurs in Sad Shep., 1.4.7–8: ‘The smoother ewes are ready to receive / The mounting rams again.’
213 fells fleeces.
214 beestning the colustrum, or first milk drawn from an animal after it gives birth, often very thick and curdled: at this time, thought to be dangerous to give to the calf. The usual form is beestings, and this is perhaps what Jonson wrote.
214 kine;] F3; Kine F2
217 tod] F2 (Tode)
217 tod fox.
217 brock badger. The tod and brock are again cited as enemies to sheep in Sad Shep., 1.4.28, 32.
220 Maenalus Arcadian mountain, associated with Pan. See Theocritus, 1.123–4; Virgil, Eclogues, 8.22–5, and Georgics, 1.17.
224 hirelings hired servants. Presumably this mildly contemptuous word refers to the Boeotians, and through them to the unruly subjects over whom the aristocratic performers are political masters. Cf. Sad Shep., 2.5.15–16: ‘Good honest shepherds, masters of your flocks, / Simple and virtuous men, no others’ hirelings’.
224 still continually.
a note on the masquers No masquers are mentioned by name in the records for Pan’s Ann.