Georeferencing the Early Modern London Book Trade: 1. Theory without Practice
![Screen capture of the ESTC homepage. Screen capture of the ESTC homepage.](graphics/estc_homepage.png)
The following blog post identifies a disjunction in how the geohumanities
spatial turnhas influenced theoretical literature in print culture studies as compared to practical, bibliographic datasets. First, I provide an overview of recent literature in print culture studies and geography, noting an increasing theoretical interest in and understanding of the spatiality of the historic book trade, particularly the early modern English book trade. I then provide an overview of digital bibliographic databases, noting the absence of spatially relevant data points and structures. When contrasted with the abundance of spatial theories in print culture studies, the lack of geocoded bibliographic data can only be regarded as an
untapped potentialfor print historians. By geocoding bibliographic datasets, print historians, I suggest, can develop new and exciting research opportunities for their discipline.
In the introduction to GeoHumanities: Art, History, Text at the Edge of Place (2011), the editors refer to a
rapidly growing zone of creative interaction between geography and the humanities(Richardson, Luria, Ketchum, and Dear 3), which they call the
geohumanities.As defined by these editors, the geohumanities involves humanities and geography scholars alike researching how spatiality manifests in cultural texts. In print culture studies, the geohumanities
spatial turnis evident. Many print historians refer to the
geography of the bookas an emerging, interdisciplinary field of inquiry concerned with the spatiality of print production, dissemination, and reception (Howsam 57; MacDonald and Black 505; Keighren 745; Ogborn and Withers 1). The term geography of the book is itself a reference to the sixth chapter of Lucien Fevbre and Henri-Jean Martin’s The Coming of the Book (1958; trans. 1976), which is considered by many to be a seminal text in the field. In the sixth chapter of The Coming of the Book, titled
Geography of the Book,Fevbre and Martin trace the processes that enabled the book trade to transition from a nomadic, highly specialized trade in the fifteenth century to a centralized, commercial trade in the eighteenth century; for doing so, they are considered by many to be the first to think about print culture in explicitly spatial terms. Miles Ogborn and Charles Withers (2010), however, point out that the geography of the book is nearly inseparable from the material history of the book more generally:
the recognition of the materiality of the book means that it is an object that must have geography. Its making can be located and its movement can be mapped. Its history as an object is shaped by where it is made and where it can subsequently be found. This makes for many possible geographies. The material conditions of production and circulation of books take place on every scale from that of the printed page itself to global networks of trade and empire. (Ogborn and Withers 12)For Ogborn and Withers, as for other print historians and geohumanists, the geography of the book constitutes not so much a new topic but rather a fundamentally new way of thinking about existing topics in print culture studies.
Despite the increasingly theoretical understanding of the geography of the book, historians of early modern English print culture have been markedly slow to pursue
bibliographic applications of such theories. In the specific field of early modern
print culture studies, Blayney (1990) and Pantzer and Rider (1991) serve as the only concrete attempts to geo-reference and map bibliographic datasets.1 Blayney’s The Bookshops in Paul’s Cross Churchyard (1990) describes, locates, and maps the sites of the individual bookshops that proliferated
throughout Paul’s Cross Churchyard in the seventeenth century. Likewise, Pantzer’s first and third appendices in volume
three of the Short-Title Catalogue (1991) index and map STC entries by the address of their printer and/or bookseller. In today’s age of digital
scholarship and web-based collaboration, it is a major drawback that both Blayney (1990) and Pantzer and Rider (1991) are published exclusively in print.
Though historians of early modern English print culture have undoubtedly embraced
information technology and the digital humanities, they have yet fully to include
complex spatial considerations in their information architecture. Popular databases
and digital archives such as the English Short Title Catalogue (ESTC), Early English Books Online (EEBO), British Book Trade Index (BBTI), and London Book Trades Database (LBTD) offer researchers a wealth of useful data, often cross-referenced and downloadable;
none of this data, however, contains geo-coordinates or geographically precise data
points (i.e., more precise than
London) for place of printing or bookselling. The English Short Title Catalogue (ESTC), for example, contains over 460,000 MARC-tagged database entries of early printed books. Database entries contain unique tags for data points such as book title, author, and publication year. They do not contain a unique tag for the address(es) associated with each book. Address information is included in data field 260|b along with the printers’ and/or booksellers’ name(s) as described by the book’s imprint. ESTC record number 006182591 serves as an example:
260|a London : |b Printed by Thomas Creede, for Tho. Millington, and Iohn Busby. And
are to be sold at his house in Carter Lane, next the Powle head, |c 1600.
(ESTC 006182591)
Because of the way the imprint data is parsed in field 260, it is very difficult for
a programmer to harvest the address information using any form of regular, field-based
script. Evidently, the ESTC and similar bibliographic databases are designed to support queries about material
books (e.g. outputs by year, author, region, etc.), while the BBTI and similar databases are designed to support queries about people (e.g., stationers
by year and region, output by stationer, etc.). No database currently exists [in 2014]
that supports dynamic and complex queries about the spatiality of bibliographic information.
It is high time that programmers, encoders, print historians, and geographers collaborate
to develop a database (or series of databases) that geocode(s) the information that
already exists in online resources such as the STC and BBTI. The need for such a database has been voiced by numerous scholars across disciplines
and specializations (Black 79; F. Black, MacDonald, and J.M. Black 11; Gregory, Kemp, and Mostern 15; Howsam 57; Keighren 750; MacDonald and Black 507). Fiona Black, a print historian primarily interested in the eighteenth- and nineteenth-century
Canadian book trade, proclaims that
[t]here are dramas pertaining to the spatial contexts of print culture waiting to be explored [through the application of information technologies](Black 109). In the field of early modern print culture studies, many of these
spatial dramastake place in the city of London. A database that dynamically links information about London printers, publishers, booksellers, and printed books with spatial data points such as toponyms and geo-coordinates would undoubtedly uncover important, new research questions about the early modern book trade: What was the spatial distribution of printers, publishers, and booksellers in early modern London? How did this distribution change between 1475 and 1640? Were certain genres of printed books printed and/or sold in certain areas of the city? What was the median distance between where a book was printed and where it was sold? Such questions are of enormous relevance to early modern English print historians and demonstrate the significant potential of a geocoded bibliographic database. The following two blog posts will discuss what such a database might look like and how it might be created.
Notes
- In addition to Blayney (1990) and Pantzer and Rider (1991), a number of articles, chapters, and monographs engage extensively with primary data pertaining to the spatiality of the early modern London book trade. See, for instance, Robin Myers, Michael Harris, and Giles Mandelbrote’s edited collection of essays titled The London Book Trade: Topographies of Print in the Metropolis from the Sixteenth Century (2003); see also James Raven’s Bookscape: Geographies of Printing and Publishing in London before 1800 (2014). I believe that such works must be classified as historiographies rather than bibliographies, however, because they contain detailed, conceptual discussions of the topic rather than exhaustive datasets. (TLG)↑
References
-
Citation
Black, Fiona A., Bertrum H. MacDonald, and J. Malcom Black.Geographic Information Systems: A New Research Tool for Book History.
Book History 1.1 (1998): 11–31. doi:10.1353/bh.1998.0001.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Black, Fiona A.Constructing the Spaces of Print Culture: Book Historians’ Visualization Preferences.
Geographies of the Book. Ed. Miles Ogborn and Charles W. J. Withers. Burlington: Ashgate, 2010. 79–108. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Blayney, Peter W. The Bookshops in Paul’s Cross Churchyard. London: Bibliographical Society, 1990. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
British Book Trade Index. Dev. Peter Isaac and Maureen Bell. U of Oxford. http://bbti.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Early English Books Online (EEBO). Proquest LLC.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
English Short Title Catalogue. British Library.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Fevbre, Lucien, and Henri-Jean Martin. The Coming of the Book: The Impact of Printing, 1450–1800. Trans. David Gerard. London: Verso, 1997. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Gregory, Ian, Karen K. Kemp, and Ruth Mostern.Geographical Information and Historical Research: Current Progress and Future Directions.
History and Computing 13.1 (2001): 7–23.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Howsam, Leslie. Old Books and New Histories: An Orientation to Studies in Book and Print Culture. Toronto: U of Toronto P, 2006. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Keighren, Innes M.Geographies of the Book: Review and Prospect.
Geography Compass 7.11 (2013): 745–753. doi:10.1111/gec3.12083.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
MacDonald, Bertrum H., and Fiona A. Black.Using GIS for Spatial and Temporal Analyses in Print Culture Studies: Some Opportunities and Challenges.
Social Science History 24.3 (2000): 505–536. doi:10.1017/S0145553200010282.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Myers, Robin, Michael Harris, and Giles Mandelbrote, eds. The London Book Trade: Topographies of Print in the Metropolis from the Sixteenth Century. New Castle and London: Oak Knoll P and British Library, 2003. 21–43. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Ogborn, Miles, and Charles W. J. Withers.Introduction: Book Geography, Book History.
Geographies of the Book. Ed. Miles Ogborn and Charles W. J. Withers. Burlington: Ashgate, 2010. 1–28. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Pantzer, Katherine F., and Philip R. Rider. A Short-Title Catalogue of Books Printed in England, Scotland, & Ireland and of English Books Printed Abroad, 1475–1640. Began by A.W. Pollard and G.R. Redgrave. 3 vols. London: Bibliographical Society, 1991. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Raven, James. Bookscape: Geographies of Printing and Publishing in London before 1800. London: British Library, 2014. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Richardson, Douglas, Sarah Luria, Jim Ketchum, and Michael Dear.Introducing the Geohumanities.
GeoHumanities; Art, History, Text at the Edge of Place. Ed. Michael Dear, Jim Ketchum, Sarah Luria, and Douglas Richardson. New York: Routledge, 2011. 3–4. Print.This item is cited in the following documents:
-
Citation
Turner, Michael, L., dev. London Book Trades. Oxford Bibliographical Society. http://lbt.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/mediawiki/index.php/Main_Page.
Cite this page
MLA citation
Georeferencing the Early Modern London Book Trade: 1. Theory without PracticeThe Map of Early Modern London, Edition 7.0, edited by , U of Victoria, 05 May 2022, mapoflondon.uvic.ca/edition/7.0/BLOG16.htm.
Chicago citation
Georeferencing the Early Modern London Book Trade: 1. Theory without PracticeThe Map of Early Modern London, Edition 7.0. Ed. . Victoria: University of Victoria. Accessed May 05, 2022. mapoflondon.uvic.ca/edition/7.0/BLOG16.htm.
APA citation
The Map of Early Modern London (Edition 7.0). Victoria: University of Victoria. Retrieved from https://mapoflondon.uvic.ca/editions/7.0/BLOG16.htm.
2022. Georeferencing the Early Modern London Book Trade: 1. Theory without Practice
In (Ed), RIS file (for RefMan, RefWorks, EndNote etc.)
Provider: University of Victoria Database: The Map of Early Modern London Content: text/plain; charset="utf-8" TY - ELEC A1 - Landels-Gruenewald, Tye ED - Jenstad, Janelle T1 - Georeferencing the Early Modern London Book Trade: 1. Theory without Practice T2 - The Map of Early Modern London ET - 7.0 PY - 2022 DA - 2022/05/05 CY - Victoria PB - University of Victoria LA - English UR - https://mapoflondon.uvic.ca/edition/7.0/BLOG16.htm UR - https://mapoflondon.uvic.ca/edition/7.0/xml/standalone/BLOG16.xml ER -
TEI citation
<bibl type="mla"><author><name ref="#LAND2"><surname>Landels-Gruenewald</surname>,
<forename>Tye</forename></name></author>. <title level="a">Georeferencing the Early
Modern London Book Trade: 1. Theory without Practice</title> <title level="m">The
Map of Early Modern London</title>, Edition <edition>7.0</edition>, edited by <editor><name
ref="#JENS1"><forename>Janelle</forename> <surname>Jenstad</surname></name></editor>,
<publisher>U of Victoria</publisher>, <date when="2022-05-05">05 May 2022</date>,
<ref target="https://mapoflondon.uvic.ca/edition/7.0/BLOG16.htm">mapoflondon.uvic.ca/edition/7.0/BLOG16.htm</ref>.</bibl>
Personography
-
Joey Takeda
JT
Programmer, 2018-present. Junior Programmer, 2015-2017. Research Assistant, 2014-2017. Joey Takeda was a graduate student at the University of British Columbia in the Department of English (Science and Technology research stream). He completed his BA honours in English (with a minor in Women’s Studies) at the University of Victoria in 2016. His primary research interests included diasporic and indigenous Canadian and American literature, critical theory, cultural studies, and the digital humanities.Roles played in the project
-
Abstract Author
-
Author
-
CSS Editor
-
Compiler
-
Conceptor
-
Copy Editor
-
Editor
-
Encoder
-
Geo-Coordinate Researcher
-
Junior Programmer
-
Markup Editor
-
Post-Conversion Editor
-
Programmer
-
Proofreader
-
Researcher
-
Toponymist
-
Transcriber
-
Transcription Proofreader
Contributions by this author
Joey Takeda is a member of the following organizations and/or groups:
Joey Takeda is mentioned in the following documents:
Joey Takeda authored or edited the following items in MoEML’s bibliography:
-
Jenstad, Janelle and Joseph Takeda.
Making the RA Matter: Pedagogy, Interface, and Practices.
Making Things and Drawing Boundaries: Experiments in the Digital Humanities. Ed. Jentery Sayers. Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 2018. Print.
-
-
Katie Tanigawa
KT
Project Manager, 2015-2019. Katie Tanigawa was a doctoral candidate at the University of Victoria. Her dissertation focused on representations of poverty in Irish modernist literature. Her additional research interests included geospatial analyses of modernist texts and digital humanities approaches to teaching and analyzing literature.Roles played in the project
-
Author
-
Conceptor
-
Encoder
-
Geo-Coordinate Researcher
-
Managing Editor
-
Markup Editor
-
Project Manager
-
Proofreader
-
Transcription Proofreader
Contributions by this author
Katie Tanigawa is a member of the following organizations and/or groups:
Katie Tanigawa is mentioned in the following documents:
-
-
Tye Landels-Gruenewald
TLG
Data Manager, 2015-2016. Research Assistant, 2013-2015. Tye completed his undergraduate honours degree in English at the University of Victoria in 2015.Roles played in the project
-
Author
-
CSS Editor
-
Compiler
-
Conceptor
-
Copy Editor
-
Data Manager
-
Editor
-
Encoder
-
Geo-Coordinate Researcher
-
Markup Editor
-
Metadata Architect
-
Proofreader
-
Researcher
-
Toponymist
-
Transcriber
-
Transcription Proofreader
Contributions by this author
Tye Landels-Gruenewald is a member of the following organizations and/or groups:
Tye Landels-Gruenewald is mentioned in the following documents:
-
-
Kim McLean-Fiander
KMF
Director of Pedagogy and Outreach, 2015–2020. Associate Project Director, 2015. Assistant Project Director, 2013-2014. MoEML Research Fellow, 2013. Kim McLean-Fiander comes to The Map of Early Modern London from the Cultures of Knowledge digital humanities project at the University of Oxford, where she was the editor of Early Modern Letters Online, an open-access union catalogue and editorial interface for correspondence from the sixteenth to eighteenth centuries. She is currently Co-Director of a sister project to EMLO called Women’s Early Modern Letters Online (WEMLO). In the past, she held an internship with the curator of manuscripts at the Folger Shakespeare Library, completed a doctorate at Oxford on paratext and early modern women writers, and worked a number of years for the Bodleian Libraries and as a freelance editor. She has a passion for rare books and manuscripts as social and material artifacts, and is interested in the development of digital resources that will improve access to these materials while ensuring their ongoing preservation and conservation. An avid traveler, Kim has always loved both London and maps, and so is particularly delighted to be able to bring her early modern scholarly expertise to bear on the MoEML project.Roles played in the project
-
Associate Project Director
-
Author
-
CSS Editor
-
Compiler
-
Conceptor
-
Copy Editor
-
Data Manager
-
Director of Pedagogy and Outreach
-
Editor
-
Encoder
-
Geo-Coordinate Researcher
-
Managing Editor
-
Markup Editor
-
Metadata Architect
-
Research Fellow
-
Toponymist
-
Transcriber
-
Transcription Proofreader
-
Vetter
Contributions by this author
Kim McLean-Fiander is a member of the following organizations and/or groups:
Kim McLean-Fiander is mentioned in the following documents:
-
-
Janelle Jenstad
JJ
Janelle Jenstad is Associate Professor of English at the University of Victoria, Director of The Map of Early Modern London, and PI of Linked Early Modern Drama Online. She has taught at Queen’s University, the Summer Academy at the Stratford Festival, the University of Windsor, and the University of Victoria. With Jennifer Roberts-Smith and Mark Kaethler, she co-edited Shakespeare’s Language in Digital Media (Routledge). She has prepared a documentary edition of John Stow’s A Survey of London (1598 text) for MoEML and is currently editing The Merchant of Venice (with Stephen Wittek) and Heywood’s 2 If You Know Not Me You Know Nobody for DRE. Her articles have appeared in Digital Humanities Quarterly, Renaissance and Reformation,Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies, Early Modern Literary Studies, Elizabethan Theatre, Shakespeare Bulletin: A Journal of Performance Criticism, and The Silver Society Journal. Her book chapters have appeared (or will appear) in Institutional Culture in Early Modern Society (Brill, 2004), Shakespeare, Language and the Stage, The Fifth Wall: Approaches to Shakespeare from Criticism, Performance and Theatre Studies (Arden/Thomson Learning, 2005), Approaches to Teaching Othello (Modern Language Association, 2005), Performing Maternity in Early Modern England (Ashgate, 2007), New Directions in the Geohumanities: Art, Text, and History at the Edge of Place (Routledge, 2011), Early Modern Studies and the Digital Turn (Iter, 2016), Teaching Early Modern English Literature from the Archives (MLA, 2015), Placing Names: Enriching and Integrating Gazetteers (Indiana, 2016), Making Things and Drawing Boundaries (Minnesota, 2017), and Rethinking Shakespeare’s Source Study: Audiences, Authors, and Digital Technologies (Routledge, 2018).Roles played in the project
-
Abstract Author
-
Author
-
Author (Preface)
-
Author of Preface
-
Compiler
-
Conceptor
-
Copy Editor
-
Course Instructor
-
Course Supervisor
-
Data Manager
-
Editor
-
Encoder
-
Geo-Coordinate Researcher
-
Markup Editor
-
Peer Reviewer
-
Project Director
-
Proofreader
-
Researcher
-
Toponymist
-
Transcriber
-
Transcription Proofreader
-
Vetter
Contributions by this author
Janelle Jenstad is a member of the following organizations and/or groups:
Janelle Jenstad is mentioned in the following documents:
Janelle Jenstad authored or edited the following items in MoEML’s bibliography:
-
Jenstad, Janelle and Joseph Takeda.
Making the RA Matter: Pedagogy, Interface, and Practices.
Making Things and Drawing Boundaries: Experiments in the Digital Humanities. Ed. Jentery Sayers. Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 2018. Print. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
Building a Gazetteer for Early Modern London, 1550-1650.
Placing Names. Ed. Merrick Lex Berman, Ruth Mostern, and Humphrey Southall. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana UP, 2016. 129-145. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
The Burse and the Merchant’s Purse: Coin, Credit, and the Nation in Heywood’s 2 If You Know Not Me You Know Nobody.
The Elizabethan Theatre XV. Ed. C.E. McGee and A.L. Magnusson. Toronto: P.D. Meany, 2002. 181–202. Print. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
Early Modern Literary Studies 8.2 (2002): 5.1–26..The City Cannot Hold You
: Social Conversion in the Goldsmith’s Shop. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
The Silver Society Journal 10 (1998): 40–43.The Gouldesmythes Storehowse
: Early Evidence for Specialisation. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
Lying-in Like a Countess: The Lisle Letters, the Cecil Family, and A Chaste Maid in Cheapside.
Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 34 (2004): 373–403. doi:10.1215/10829636–34–2–373. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
Public Glory, Private Gilt: The Goldsmiths’ Company and the Spectacle of Punishment.
Institutional Culture in Early Modern Society. Ed. Anne Goldgar and Robert Frost. Leiden: Brill, 2004. 191–217. Print. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
Smock Secrets: Birth and Women’s Mysteries on the Early Modern Stage.
Performing Maternity in Early Modern England. Ed. Katherine Moncrief and Kathryn McPherson. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2007. 87–99. Print. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
Using Early Modern Maps in Literary Studies: Views and Caveats from London.
GeoHumanities: Art, History, Text at the Edge of Place. Ed. Michael Dear, James Ketchum, Sarah Luria, and Doug Richardson. London: Routledge, 2011. Print. -
Jenstad, Janelle.
Versioning John Stow’s A Survey of London, or, What’s New in 1618 and 1633?.
Janelle Jenstad Blog. https://janellejenstad.com/2013/03/20/versioning-john-stows-a-survey-of-london-or-whats-new-in-1618-and-1633/. -
Shakespeare, William. The Merchant of Venice. Ed. Janelle Jenstad. Internet Shakespeare Editions. U of Victoria. http://internetshakespeare.uvic.ca/Library/Texts/MV/.
-
Stow, John. A SVRVAY OF LONDON. Contayning the Originall, Antiquity, Increase, Moderne estate, and description of that Citie, written in the yeare 1598. by Iohn Stow Citizen of London. Also an Apologie (or defence) against the opinion of some men, concerning that Citie, the greatnesse thereof. With an Appendix, containing in Latine, Libellum de situ & nobilitate Londini: written by William Fitzstephen, in the raigne of Henry the second. Ed. Janelle Jenstad and the MoEML Team. MoEML. Transcribed.
-
-
Blaine Greteman
BG
Blaine Greteman is an associate professor of English at the University of Iowa, specializing in early modern literature, digital humanities, and nonfiction. In 2013 he published The Poetics and Politics of Youth in the Age of Milton, and he writes regularly for popular publications, including The New Republic.Roles played in the project
-
Vetter
-
-
Martin D. Holmes
MDH
Programmer at the University of Victoria Humanities Computing and Media Centre (HCMC). Martin ported the MOL project from its original PHP incarnation to a pure eXist database implementation in the fall of 2011. Since then, he has been lead programmer on the project and has also been responsible for maintaining the project schemas. He was a co-applicant on MoEML’s 2012 SSHRC Insight Grant.Roles played in the project
-
Abstract Author
-
Author
-
Conceptor
-
Editor
-
Encoder
-
Geo-Coordinate Researcher
-
Markup Editor
-
Post-Conversion Editor
-
Programmer
-
Proofreader
-
Researcher
Contributions by this author
Martin D. Holmes is a member of the following organizations and/or groups:
Martin D. Holmes is mentioned in the following documents:
-
Locations
-
Paul’s Cross Churchyard
Paul’s Cross Churchyard, also known as the Cross Yard, is the area on the northeast side of St. Paul’s Cathedral. It was one of the principal bookselling areas in early modern London.Paul’s Cross Churchyard is mentioned in the following documents: