Begbie discusses British Columbia’s finances relating to property value and public revenue; British Columbia’s population and the factors leading to its decreasing numbers; and British Columbia’s resources. Begbie briefly describes the weather and its impact on farmers and miners in the colony.
Robinson’s minute highlights the main factors in Begbie’s letter affecting British Columbia’s economy. In response to Buckingham’s minute, Robinson further minutes why it is difficult to communicate between Richfield and Victoria.
Extract of a letter from Judge Begbie to his Brother Thomas Stirling
Begbie
4, Mansion House Place, City, dated Richfield 5th August 1867.
As to my coming home on leave next Winter, I have but a plain and
simple answer, I can't afford it: whether owing in part or in whole
to the policy pursued of endeavoring to kill Victoria, or not, things
are now, I think, nearly as low as they can stand lower we shall not
exist at all. It does not follow that even with a change of policy,
the Colony would improve suddenly; but in fact I think any change
of policy extremely doubtful. There are perhaps three tests of the
actual situation of the Colony, value of property, public revenue,
and population. As to the value of property, it is in general perhaps
about worth 6d in the £ of what it was worth in 1863-4 when the new
policy was inaugerated. I mean that property worth £100 then,
would now perhaps fetch at Auction £2 or £3. I am speaking of
Land, Flour & Staple articles of consumption of course bear still a
fair price. In Victoria, prime lots being well held, have been
rarely in the market, but there was one corner block with houses &c
sold the other day for £640 by Auction, which in 1864 would have
been worth from £11,000 to £12,000. I don't think therefore that
the Colony can go much lower according to this test.
Now as to public revenue, the estimates I dare say are not
exactly arranged according to my notions of what would be useful
expenditure: but they are not extravagant in amount considering
the territory to be administered is as large as France. The total
estimated expenditure was in round numbers $700,000 = £140,000,how
how far this has been met by the receipts you may guess from the fact
that I have only received 2 months pay for the 7 months now due. I
think it is extremely doubtful indeed whether I shall receive anything
like the whole £1,200, Salary by the end of the Year, perhaps another
£200.
Lastly as to population—the population, mining and migratory, of
the present combined colonies is smaller than the fixed inhabiting
population of Victoria & Esquimalt was alone two or three years ago.
Our mining and migratory population is smaller than it was then, and
I am sorry to say nearly all the settled families have left. It was
only in Victoria that any families could be said to be settled. I question
if there ever have been a dozen on the mainland of B.C. (apart from
the Officials and their families), and in 1865-6-7 every Steamer almost
has taken away from one to half a dozen—none have replaced them.
The Auctioneers have at last scarcely been able to give away the
"household furniture of a family about to leave the Colony"
advertisements of which have filled the papers.
Now there can be no disputing these 3 facts—depopulation,
annihilation of the value of landed property, and disappointment in
the revenue, to such an extent that even the judicial salary (which
ought to be a pretty sure payment) is, as to the greater part, unpaid.
I have heard of some resumption of payments lately, but quite
unauthoritatively. I have applied to know whether I can draw, but have
received no answer. It takes with our present mail service from 3
to 5 weeks to get an answer from below, e.g. some Criminals were
sentenced here on 2nd July & an express left on 3rd July: we
have as yet no reply as to the disposal of them—except that I understand
by telegraph, that written orders are on their way up.
Besides, the Colony, though so low that, as I said before if it
falls two steps lower itmust must I should say, be abandoned, may rise.
I still believe as fully as ever that it is the best Gold Mining
Country in the world, to say nothing of Silver, Copper and Coal, the
latter the best on the Pacific Coast, & both Silver and Copper known
to exist. But how are they to be discovered except by the merest
fluke, when our whole effective population is so small? Not more
than 3,000 probably for mining purposes & these nearly wholly taken
up with gold hunting. As to Silver indeed there is reported a vein
equal to anything in Washoe. Three separate parcels of several CWT
gave results $1,500, $1,300, $604 to the ton.
If the Box leaves by middle of November I ought to receive it
in January, it will be hardly worse weather than down Country,
than what we are having up here this Year. This morning it was
snowing heavily for 2 or 3 hours, it did not lie except up the
hills where all was white. It has snowed here two or three times
the last month, in fact I have often said that I have spent about 14
or 15 Winters in this Colony—7 in Cariboo and 8 or 9 down below.
There is great croaking among the Farmers, who are not very numerous
however, they are having a great deal of cold and wet, not snow of
course, nobody can farm up here, about 4,500 feet high in the Air in
this latitude, on the other hand the wet weather is good for the
Miner, plenty of water. The out turn is about 2,000 oz per week,
perhaps, which considering our scanty population, I don't believe
there are much over 2,000 Miners, is pretty good.
[No signature]
Minutes by CO staff
Mr Elliot
This is a very interesting Extract of a letter from Judge Begbie
to his brother & bears on the financial position of B. Columbiawh
is now under your conson.
The most noticeable points are
1. that property worth £100 in 1863/4wd now fetch from £2 to £3.
2. that the Salaries are five months in arrear.
3. the difficulty of communication with Victoria & N Westr.
4. the large "out turn" of Gold at the Mines.