Lord Carnarvon
                     I think we must be just before we are generous. It may have been very
                     proper on the part of the Governor to grant extra-pay to the Ships
                     companies of the 
Satellite & 
Plumper, who being sent to the 
Gulf of
                        Georgia for a 
special surveying service have been employed on a
                     
Colonial service, which afforded them abundant opportunities
                     for desertion; but to extend the same bounty "to the Crews of any of HM
                     ships visiting 
VanCouver's Island," proper also as that step might be,
                     would be adding greatly to our

 already heavy bill for 
B. Columbia.
                     All the expenses we have been receiving here for the R. Engineers—all
                     
                     the salaries of the Est we have unavoidably created—must,
                     as we believe, & hope be repaid to us. To secure that important
                     object is our first cons: & I 
w dissuade encouraging the Adm
                     to expect that anything more can be done for the Navy than has been done.
                     In my opinion the ans to this Letter should be to the effect that
                     [the extra pay to 
w allusion is made was granted under peculiar
                     circumstances of difficulty & to guard against the risk of desertion
                     
w was then imminent. That as such it had Sir E's approval as a
                     wise precaution.
                     Further]
                     
                     if the Colonial Authorities have the means of increasing the pay of the
                     Sailors in HMS visiting 
B. Columbia, and if the circes of the case should
                     in the opinion of the Authorities justify such a step Sir 
E. Lytton
                     would not object to sanctioning it. But that the 
Admiralty must
                     distinctly understand that exceedingly heavy charges will devolve at once
                     upon the Colonial resources on account of the establishment of the
                     Colony—that these charges must be 
first defrayed, and that extra
                     pay to the Crews cannot, under any circes, be given, if by
                     so doing the ways & means of the new settlement are crippled.