Letter 10, to John Donne (1609)

 Letter 10, to John Donne

A letter from Ben Jonson to Dr Donne, in clearing himself upon a former

accusation.


Sir,

You cannot but believe how dear and reverend your friendship is to me (though

all testimony on my part hath been  too short to express me) and therefore would 5

I meet it with all obedience. My mind is not yet so deafened by injuries but it hath

an ear for counsel. Yet in this point, that you presently dissuade, I wonder how I

am misunderstood; or that you should call that an imaginary right which is the

proper justice, that every clear man owes to his innocency. Exasperations I intend

none, for truth cannot be sharp but to ill natures, or such weak ones whom the 10

ill spirit’s suspicion or credulity still possess.  My Lady may believe whisperings,

receive tales, suspect and condemn my honesty, and I may not answer, on the

pain of losing her; as if she, who had this prejudice of me, were not already lost.

Oh, no, she will do me no hurt, she will think and speak well of  any faculties.

She cannot there judge me; or if she could, I would exchange all glory (if I had 15

all men’s abilities) which could come that way for honest simplicity. But there is

a greater penalty threatened, the loss of you, my true friend; for others, I reckon

not, who were never had; you have so subscribed yourself. Alas! how easy is a man

accused, that is forsaken of defence! Well, my modesty shall sit down, and (let the

world call it guilt, or what it will) I will yet thank you, that counsel me to a silence 20

in these  oppressures, when confidence in my right and friends may abandon me.

And, lest yourself may undergo some hazard for my questioned reputation, and

draw jealousies or hatred upon you, I desire to be left to mine own innocence:

which shall acquit me, or heaven shall be guilty.

Your ever true lover. 25

Letter 10 From A Collection of Letters, Made by Sir Tobie Matthew, Kt., with a Character of the Most Excellent Lady, Lucy, Countess of Carlisle by the Same Author, to Which Are Added Many Letters of His Own to Several Persons of Honour Who Were Contemporary with Him (1660) 328–9. The collection was prepared by Donne’s son, John Donne junior. The precise date and circumstances of this letter are unknown. ‘My Lady’ (11) must however be Donne’s and Jonson’s friend and patroness, Lucy, Countess of Bedford (?1581–1627), who is addressed in Epigr. 76, 84, and 94, and danced in several of Jonson’s masques. De Luna (1967), 154–70, guesses that Jonson is attempting to recover the Countess’s good graces after his satirical attack on her friend Cecilia Bulstrode in ‘An Epigram on the Court Pucelle’ (see Informations, 71–2n., 520–2n., Und. 49n.). Jonson and Donne both wrote in admiring tribute to Cecilia at her death on 4 August 1609 (see ‘Bulstrode’ and Letter 11, headnote). Jonson’s change of heart may perhaps have been prompted by the disturbances to which the present letter alludes. This admittedly speculative identification determines the letter’s placing in this edition. Donne was later to act once again as mediator between Jonson and friends whom he had offended, after Jonson seemingly satirized Inigo Jones too openly in an early version of Bart. Fair: see Donne’s letter of 17 July 1613 to an unknown correspondent in Gosse (1899), 2.16, and discussion in Bald (1970), 196–7, Donaldson (2011), ch. 16, and Creaser, Introduction to Bart. Fair, this edition. [Editor: Ian Donaldson]
5 too short Referring not to the brevity of Jonson’s and Donne’s acquaintance, as De Luna (1967), 155, n. 22 imagines – they had probably been acquainted since the 1590s – but to the brevity of Jonson’s poetic tributes to Donne in Epigr. 23 and 96.
11 My Lady Lucy, Countess of Bedford.
14 any Perhaps a misreading of ‘my’, as H&S conjecture.
21 oppressures oppressions, tyrannical circumstances (not recorded in OED).[Editor: Ian Donaldson]