<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<TEI.2 id="panel_147_french">
   <teiHeader>
      <fileDesc>
         <titleStmt>
            <title>Hybrid Cyber-Librarians: The CLIR Post-Doctoral Fellowship in Scholarly Information Resources for Humanists</title>
            <author>
               <name reg="French, Amanda">Amanda French</name>
            </author>
            <author>
               <name reg="Unsworth, John">John Unsworth</name>
            </author>
            <author>
               <name reg="Nutter, Susan">Susan Nutter</name>
            </author>
            <author>
               <name reg="Michalak, Sarah">Sarah Michalak</name>
            </author>
            <author>
               <name reg="Hswe, Patricia">Patricia Hswe</name>
            </author>
            <author>
               <name reg="Rentfrow, Daphnee">Daphnee Rentfrow</name>
            </author>
            <respStmt>
               <resp>Marked up by </resp>
               <name reg="Holmes, Martin">Martin Holmes</name>
               <lb/>
               <name reg="Baer, Patricia">Patricia Baer</name>
            </respStmt>
         </titleStmt>
         <publicationStmt>
            <p>Marked up to be included in the ACH/ALLC 2005 Conference Abstracts book.</p>
         </publicationStmt>
         <sourceDesc>
            <p>None</p>
         </sourceDesc>
      </fileDesc>
      <profileDesc>
         <textClass>
            <classCode>panel</classCode>
            <keywords>
               <list>
                  <item>CLIR Post-Doctoral Fellowship</item>
                  <item>scholarly information resources</item>
                  <item>Library Science</item>
               </list>
            </keywords>
         </textClass>
      </profileDesc>
      <revisionDesc>
         <list>
            <item>MDH: Created from John Bradley's XML <date value="2005-03">March 2005</date>
            </item>
            <item>MDH: Revisions merged <date value="2005-03-23">23 March 2005</date>
            </item>
            <item>MDH: Proofed by Ray Siemens <date value="2005-04-02">2 April 2005</date>
            </item>
            <item>MDH: After some confusion with regard to the difference between authors, presenters, participants etc., the Programme Chair instructed that the names of panelists must appear on the schedule, so they were added  into the document as authors <date value="2005-06-09">9 June 2005</date>. The new list of panelists now differs substantially from the original list.</item>
         </list>
      </revisionDesc>
   </teiHeader>
   <text>
      <front>
         <docTitle n="Hybrid Cyber-Librarians: The CLIR Post-Doctoral Fellowship in Scholarly Information Resources for Humanists">
            <titlePart>Hybrid Cyber-Librarians: The CLIR Post-Doctoral Fellowship in Scholarly Information Resources for Humanists</titlePart>
         </docTitle>
         <docAuthor>
            <name reg="French, Amanda">Amanda French</name>
            <address>
               <addrLine>amanda_french@ncsu.edu</addrLine>
            </address>
         </docAuthor>
         <titlePart type="affil">North Carolina State University</titlePart>
         <docAuthor>
            <name reg="Unsworth, John">John Unsworth</name>
            <address>
               <addrLine>unsworth@uiuc.edu</addrLine>
            </address>
         </docAuthor>
         <titlePart type="affil">University of Illinois</titlePart>
         <docAuthor>
            <name reg="Nutter, Susan">Susan Nutter</name>
         </docAuthor>
         <titlePart type="affil">North Carolina State University Libraries</titlePart>
         <docAuthor>
            <name reg="Michalak, Sarah">Sarah Michalak</name>
         </docAuthor>
         <titlePart type="affil">North Carolina State University Libraries</titlePart>
         <docAuthor>
            <name reg="Hswe, Patricia">Patricia Hswe</name>
            <address>
               <addrLine>phswe@uiuc.edu</addrLine>
            </address>
         </docAuthor>
         <titlePart type="affil">University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign</titlePart>
         <docAuthor>
            <name reg="Rentfrow, Daphnée">Daphnée Rentfrow</name>
            <address>
               <addrLine>daphnee.rentfrow@yale.edu</addrLine>
            </address>
         </docAuthor>
         <titlePart type="affil">Yale University</titlePart>
      </front>
      <body>
         <div0>
            <p>The <title>Council on Library and Information Resources</title> (<xptr to="http://www.clir.org/"/>) has developed a unique new program of crucial interest to the membership of the <title>Association for Computers and the Humanities</title>: the <title level="m">CLIR Post-Doctoral Fellowship in Scholarly Information Resources for Humanists</title>. The stated purpose of this program, now in its first year at ten U.S. academic libraries, is <cit>
                  <q>to establish a new kind of scholarly information professional</q>
               </cit> by offering individuals with a recent Ph.D. in a humanities field a chance to acquire the experience of the academic librarian in the digital age <cit>
                  <bibl>CLIR , <xptr to="http://www.clir.org/fellowships/postdoc/postdoc.html"/>, <title level="a">Information</title>
                  </bibl>
               </cit>. <title>ACH</title> is one of the few professional associations in which scholars, librarians, and technology specialists come together as a coherent community; every one of its members is no doubt aware that communication in other venues between these three professions is highly problematic. Moreover, people who undertake humanities computing projects are frequently frustrated by the fact that their professions lack a structure that allows new-model collaborative work to be recognized and rewarded.</p>
            <p>Successful humanities computing initiatives such as the <title level="m">Institute for Advanced Technology in the Humanities</title> (<xptr to="http://www.iath.virginia.edu/"/>) at the University of Virginia could not have been possible without the enthusiastic collaboration of scholars, librarians, and technology specialists. Those involved in these initiatives understand that the nature of the work often goes beyond the collaborative or even the interdisciplinary to become what we might call the <soCalled>interprofessional</soCalled>. On humanities computing projects, it is rare to find individuals rigidly adhering to their own professional skills and duties as though on an assembly line. Usually, those who participate develop into information professionals who possess various proportions of expertise in scholarship, library science, and technology. </p>
            <p>Such interprofessional work is not credentialed, however, nor is it generally practiced outside the humanities computing community. This creates serious problems not only for individuals whose work has been interprofessional but also for the whole enterprise of digital scholarship. Scholars who have been involved in humanities computing projects are far more likely than other scholars to understand the challenges facing academic librarians in the digital age — but all scholars are beginning to expect high-level digital services from their libraries. CLIR frames this problem thus: <cit>
                  <q>Libraries digitize primary resources to respond to the demands of individual scholars, but scholars don't recognize the complexity of carrying out this task nor do they understand the demands placed on librarians who need to improve access and ensure preservation... Scholars are increasingly accepting of digital publication, while librarians are finding that the contract law that controls access to such publications makes preservation impossible and access problematic.</q>
                  <bibl>CLIR , <xptr to="http://www.clir.org/fellowships/postdoc/detail.html"/>, <title level="a">Program</title>
                  </bibl>
               </cit>
            </p>
            <p>But is the creation of a new hybrid professional the answer to problems such as these, or does a program such as the CLIR post-doctoral fellowship threaten to undermine the valuable discrete professional knowledge of librarians, scholars, and technology specialists? A recent <title level="j">Library Journal</title> article on the CLIR Post-Doctoral Fellowship takes the latter position, declaring that <cit>
                  <q>It weakens our profession when we open it to Ph.D.'s without established library credentials</q>
                  <bibl>
                     <xptr to="http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA474993"/>, Crowley</bibl>
               </cit> This perspective emphasizes the unique skills belonging to a particular profession, a perspective that might well be shared by some scholarly professionals and some technology professionals. Is the specialized knowledge of these professions endangered or diluted by the collaborations that are so common on humanities computing projects? Should interprofessional credentialization be encouraged?</p>
            <p>We suspect that the membership of ACH has much to contribute to this discussion, and we believe that the first year of the CLIR Post-Doctoral Fellowship is the ideal time to discuss the professionalization issues faced by information professionals engaged in humanities computing projects. We therefore propose a ninety-minute session in which panelists will engage in debate about the CLIR Post-Doctoral Fellowship and related professionalization and specialization issues. We invite the members of ACH to engage in this discussion of the principles behind—and future of—this attempt to credential a new species of digital scholar-librarian.</p>
         </div0>
      </body>
      <back>
         <div type="Bibliography">
            <head>Bibliography</head>
            <listBibl>
               <biblStruct>
                  <monogr>
                     <author>
                        <name reg="Council on Library and Information Resources">Council on Library and Information Resources</name>
                     </author>
                     <title level="m" type="WWW document">Post-Doctoral Fellowship in Scholarly Information Resources for Humanists: Information for Applicants</title>
                     <imprint/>
                  </monogr>
                  <note>
                     <xptr crdate="2005-03-23" to="http://www.clir.org/fellowships/postdoc/postdoc.html"/>
                  </note>
               </biblStruct>
               <biblStruct>
                  <monogr>
                     <author>
                        <name reg="Council on Library and Information Resources">Council on Library and Information Resources</name>
                     </author>
                     <title level="m" type="WWW document">Post-Doctoral Fellowship in Scholarly Information Resources for Humanists: Program Background</title>
                     <imprint/>
                  </monogr>
                  <note>
                     <xptr crdate="2005-03-23" to="http://www.clir.org/fellowships/postdoc/detail.html"/>
                  </note>
               </biblStruct>
               <biblStruct>
                  <analytic>
                     <author>
                        <name reg="Crowley, Bill">Bill Crowley</name>
                     </author>
                     <title level="a">Just Another Field?</title>
                  </analytic>
                  <monogr>
                     <title level="j">Library Journal</title>
                     <imprint>
                        <biblScope type="vol">129.18</biblScope>
                        <biblScope type="pages">44-6</biblScope>
                        <date value="2004-11-1">2004</date>
                     </imprint>
                  </monogr>
                  <note>
                     <xptr crdate="2005-03-23" to="http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA474993"/>
                  </note>
               </biblStruct>
               <biblStruct>
                  <analytic>
                     <author>
                        <name reg="Oder, Norman">Norman Oder</name>
                     </author>
                     <title level="a">New Movement for Ph.D.'s To Work in Academic Libraries</title>
                  </analytic>
                  <monogr>
                     <title level="j">Library Journal</title>
                     <imprint>
                        <biblScope type="vol">128.11</biblScope>
                        <biblScope type="pages">16-17</biblScope>
                        <date value="2003-06-15">2003</date>
                     </imprint>
                  </monogr>
                  <note>
                     <xptr crdate="2005-03-23" to="http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA302413"/>
                  </note>
               </biblStruct>
            </listBibl>
         </div>
      </back>
   </text>
</TEI.2>